It seems Itumeleng Khune can't keep his eye on one woman at a time - well, that's if you believe the latest tabloid reports.
The pair started spending a lot of time together after Itu broke up with media personality Minnie Dlamini in 2014.
Pictures of the pair together started doing the rounds on social media last year, but they never confirmed the relationship. It was also reported that Sbahle's father and stepmom did not approve of her relationship with the football star.
The goalkeeper's friends claim that the pair spent Valentine's Day apart, as Sbahle was busy and had no interest in the day. The source also added that Sbahle felt betrayed by Itumeleng's alleged cheating, because she had gone against her family's wishes when she decided to date him.
Another source claims that Sbahle is tired of competing with other girls for Itu's attention as she thought she was the only girl in his life.
The goalkeeper reportedly regrets cheating on Sbahle and still posts her pictures on social media, hoping to get her back.
Sbahle told Sunday Sun: "I don't discuss my private life with the media. I've never denied or confirmed my relationship with Khune. So I don't have anything to say."
Itu could not be reached for comment.
Although they're keeping mum about the status of their relationship, we noticed that Sbahle has deleted most of her pictures on Instagram, including ones she took with Itu.
Does this mean there's trouble in paradise, or was she just cleaning her timeline?