“You may not be told what to say, but the “scene” has to be planned & controlled. Can’t be “real” with these many people watching you,” he continued.
He went on to say that the cast is not given scripts but the structure of the show is scripted. "I’m not saying people are given scripts like actors on set. Thought that’s obvious, but this is Twitter. One has to put it in grade 3 terms. Television is about structure (and story telling) so it’s not viable to just point cameras," he wrote.
Look at how many people are in the room when they shoot #RHODurban
— Kgopolo (@PhilMphela) April 22, 2022
This is what’s meant by; reality tv, like all tv productions, is scripted.
You may not be told what to say, but the “scene” has to be planned & controlled.
Can’t be “real” with these many ppl watching you. pic.twitter.com/zlBr3kbCNu
Tweeps weigh in on his tweets with varying opinions. Some agreed with what Phil's sentiments.
@VuyaniMbuso88 tweeted" In Television studies back in varsity we were taught that there is no such thing as reality TV because a person's natural behavior is either lost or changed once they are aware that they are in front of a camera."
@bevditsie tweeted "Wow.I'm a series writer/director for reality TV. I've directed everything from BBA to Survivor South Africa etc. I completely understand and agree with what you say Phil. Once a camera comes on - 'real' loses meaning. The more the crew, the less real the reality."
Reality shows are partly scripted, I agree with Phil I remember love and hippop when moniece quit the show, one of the reasons the producers always wanted her to be a bad guy and would pressure her to share things that she ain’t comfortable to share.
— Anathi Lingani (@LinganiAnatii) April 22, 2022
Wow.
— Bev (@bevditsie) April 22, 2022
I'm a series writer/director for reality TV. I've directed everything from BBA to Survivor South Africa etc. I completely understand and agree with what you say Phil. Once a camera comes on - 'real' loses meaning. The more the crew, the less real the reality.
In Television studies back in varsity we were taught that there is no such thing as reality TV because a person's natural behavior is either lost or changed once they are aware that they are in front of a camera.
— Gatsheni (@VuyaniMbuso88) April 22, 2022
Image Cred: Showmax